The song “john Wayne Gacy Jnr”, which is mentioned below in the post on Sufjan Stevens, is not obviously about a serial killer on first listen. If you know the story of JWG because you are from Chicago, or you read about it on wikipedia, then the lyrics change shape and become more obvious.
It is an incredibly sad song, almost unbearably so. Some people have a bad reaction to a song like this, for example this listener:
Listening to this song my first reaction was “is this SOB actually trying to make me feel sympathy for JWG?” Quite frankly I don’t care what upbringing JWG had there are no mitigating circumstances for being the definition of evil.
I’ve never been so disgusted in my life. JWG is nothing short of a Monster. For his sake I hope there is a hell and I hope he rots there forever.
BOO HISS – Bill please remove this garbage from rotation.
Not that everyone has that opinion:
I never would have thought it would be possible for someone to make a song about John Wayne Gacy that would be sad and beautiful, and probably would have thought the very idea was horrible. It’s a testament to Sufjan’s talents that he pulled it off, partly by making it about more than just Gacy. Still gives me the chills, a year and a half after first hearing it.
Stevens does end up with a song that is sad and beautiful? How does keep it from being morbid or from “expressing sympathy” for JWG?
By expressing sympathy for everyone.
The song is one huge sigh at the sadness of the world: that JWG could kill, that he would get in a position where he felt he had to do so, sadness at the feeling of the relatives of the dead, that evil exists.
He ends to song by even bringing himself into this world of sadness:
And in my best behavior
I am really just like him
Look beneath the floor boards
For the secrets I have hid
This was noted on the radio station discussion board that the above quotes come from, alluding to his purported christian upbringing:
He concludes with a reference to christian scriptures that says (paraphrased) we are all sinners, whether we steal money or kill 27 people.